Skip to content

Keeping America Strong

Betcha didn’t know that small one-person con­sult­ing com­pan­ies in Canada play a vital role in keep­ing the US strong, didja? Makes you won­der why I moved to a big US-based com­pany, but I digress.

I found out just how vital these small com­pan­ies are when an asso­ci­ate pro­du­cer from a TV pro­duc­tion com­pany cold called a few months ago to see whether I’d be inter­ested in tak­ing part in their series called, yup, Keep­ing Amer­ica Strong. When I poin­ted out that I was in Canada and a one-person con­sult­ing com­pany, he respon­ded that keep­ing Canada strong would help the US bor­ders and that small com­pan­ies also play a vital role. And that the series was hos­ted by Wil­liam Shat­ner, sup­por­ted by tele­vi­sion news anchors and a Navy Admiral.

I must admit, I was intrigued, although I might have been more temp­ted had it been Leonard Nimoy host­ing rather than Wil­liam Shat­ner. Still, it was worth spend­ing another few minutes on the phone, explain­ing what XML does and how it is used by vari­ous US gov­ern­ment depart­ments such as Home­land Secur­ity. XML obvi­ously passed the test of being deemed worthy of the next step, which was to meet the field pro­du­cer who would write up the pro­posal for each “ente­pren­eur­ial com­pany” (their words) that wanted to “move for­ward in these times” (their words). At about this stage I star­ted won­der­ing just how much this was going to cost, although I was enjoy­ing the pol­ished deliv­ery of the bene­fits of being on TV with the “Amer­ican icons” (their words). Even­tu­ally I got the answer. The major celebrit­ies were donat­ing their time and energy for this import­ant endeav­our, and the only costs were a con­tri­bu­tion to the pro­duc­tion costs of a mere $US 15,000. A tad pricey for a van­ity kick, I thought. So I declined with thanks, got a nice follow-up email, and still have the fax with the details of what I missed out on. Maybe I’ll keep that for pos­ter­ity; after all, paper doesn’t degrade the same way web sites do.

Then yes­ter­day I found an Invit­a­tion for Inter­view for “For­bes Radio” on Amer­ican Air­lines in my inbox. Yup, another invit­a­tion to prove I’m one of these “innov­at­ive industry and busi­ness lead­ers, who through effect­ive col­lab­or­a­tion, pro­gress­ive strategies, improved pro­ductiv­ity, and increased agil­ity, provide com­pan­ies and indi­vidu­als a com­pet­it­ive advant­age and bet­ter qual­ity of work and life”. This oppor­tun­ity is to take part in a 3-minute inter­view to be played on Amer­ican Air­lines inf­light pro­gram, which has a “cap­tive audi­ence of 3.4 mil­lion exec­ut­ive trav­el­ers per month”, and offered at the dis­coun­ted rate of only $US 4,995! So make sure you remem­ber your iPod next time you fly on Amer­ican Airlines.

{ 55 } Comments

  1. David Ascher | Mar 10, 2005 at 9:36 pm | Permalink

    I had a sim­ilar kind of inter­ac­tion with someone who kept me on the phone for at least twenty minutes explain­ing how he would get my com­pany (Act­iveState) men­tioned in a bro­chure that they were pub­lish­ing for dis­tri­bu­tion by the UN to 56,000 decision­makers in asia, as part of a push to sup­port Linux-based products, yadda yadda yadda. He said they had 5 slots, and only one remain­ing. I asked, expect­ing little, who the other four com­pan­ies were. Unfor­tu­nately for him, he men­tioned Mozilla.org, (“some guy called Mitchell Baker”) and oth­ers, equally eas­ily reference-checkable. After a quick email to Mitchell it was clear this was a scam. Still, a remark­ably elab­or­ate scam. Given how smooth-talking the guy was, it’s sad to think of the waste of sales tal­ent involved (even if it’s enter­tain­ing at times).

  2. PhL | Mar 16, 2005 at 4:04 pm | Permalink

    Got the same call today.
    Keep­ing Amer­ica Strong

    Would like to know if the one who payed got back there investment.

    PhL

  3. R Rodriguez | Mar 25, 2005 at 9:39 pm | Permalink

    I got the same call earlier this week. I’m think­ing of call­ing them back to at least catch the wave and chase the fun. I’d be inter­ested in any­one is ahead of me in this endeavor and what they are in the pro­cess… Thanks

  4. Kera Vo | Mar 28, 2005 at 11:12 am | Permalink

    I got the email that reques­ted only the CEO or Pres­id­ent call back. I called back to find out what are the hid­den costs.

    Yes, I would also like to know the return on invest­ment from those who paid.

  5. invresinst | Apr 13, 2005 at 4:59 pm | Permalink

    I just talked to them today. I asked them what TV net­work they are on, and she (the asso­ci­ate pro­du­cer) said the Amer­ican Life Chan­nel. Has any­one ever heard of that chan­nel? I couldn’t find it on the Inter­net, nor on Comcast’s chan­nel list­ings. I also asked her what chan­nel num­ber and time slot the pro­gram airs in the LA area, and she didn’t know. Has any­one seen this pro­gram on TV?

  6. Ron Wainrib | Apr 25, 2005 at 9:26 pm | Permalink

    I actu­ally have their “pro­du­cer” com­ing to my office (home office) tomor­row morn­ing at 10 AM. The asso­ci­ate pro­du­cer who con­tac­ted me was very friendly, no big sales pres­sure, and totally up front about the $15,000.

    The $15,000 is to be paid only if you’re “selec­ted”, though they did not tell me the “cri­teria” their look­ing for. As an attor­ney, I do not plan on sign­ing any doc­u­ment or agree­ment that binds me to “accept” and pay $15,000 if I’m selec­ted (which I highly doubt any­way). IF that hap­pens, I will take them straight to court — Mas­sachu­setts has the strongest con­sumer pro­tec­tion laws in the country.

    I expect that my chances of being “selec­ted” or prob­ably less than being hit by light­ning or win­ning Mega­bucks. I called them today and learned it’s one hour of time.

    How­ever, I fig­ure, for the hell of it, I’ve spent an hour doing worse things (plus, in his “prior life”, Shat­ner was my child­hood “hero” as Cap­tain Kirk of Star Trek.

    It’s only a “scam” when they ask for the money. As I said, they were totally up-front about that, so I don’t con­sider it a “scam” — at least not yet — just my choice whether to spend an hour with their pro­du­cer. I have NO inten­tion of pay­ing them $15000 even if I’m selec­ted (I don’t have that kind of money anyway).

    If any­one is inter­ested I’ll let you know how it goes. Please e-mail me at Needtokno@comcast.net if you’d like me to follow-up after tomorrow.

    Thanks.

    Ron Wainrib
    Frank­lin, Mass

  7. Ron Wainrib | Apr 25, 2005 at 9:30 pm | Permalink

    I actu­ally have their “pro­du­cer” com­ing to my office (home office) tomor­row morn­ing at 10 AM. The asso­ci­ate pro­du­cer who con­tac­ted me was friendly and totally up front about the $15,000.

    The $15,000 is paid if you’re “selec­ted”. I do not plan on sign­ing any doc­u­ment or agree­ment that binds me to “accept” and pay $15,000 if I’m selec­ted (which I highly doubt any­way). IF that hap­pens, I will take them straight to court. I expect my chances of being “selec­ted” are less than being hit by lightning.

    I fig­ure, for the hell of it, I’ve spent an hour doing worse things (plus, in his “prior life”, Shat­ner was my child­hood “hero” as Cap­tain Kirk of Star Trek.

    I don’t con­sider it a “scam” yet — just my choice whether to spend an hour with their pro­du­cer. I have NO inten­tion of pay­ing them $15000 even if I’m selec­ted (I don’t have that kind of money any­way). If any­one is inter­ested in a follow-up, please con­tact me at Needtokno@comcast.net

    Ron Wainrib

  8. erika wilton | Apr 28, 2005 at 5:45 pm | Permalink

    I received the phone call today. I’m curi­ous how and why I was con­tac­ted. I appre­ci­ate this blog and the com­ments. My hus­band, an attor­ney, does think this is a scam. Are these people (Shat­ner, et al) that hard up for money?
    Of course I have never heard of the Amer­ican Life Chan­nel, and it all feels a little too “Up With People” for me.

  9. Martha Birnbaum | May 06, 2005 at 9:15 am | Permalink

    Add me to the list of “you-who-could-be-about-to-be-scammed”. Got a voice mail this am from an asso­ci­ate pro­duce of Keep­ing Amer­ican Strong ask­ing me to poten­tially become a chum of Wm Shat­ner, mar­ket my small busi­ness, etc. So of course I imme­di­ately googled the bunch and came upon the low­down in this news­group. I hadn’t expec­ted the scam price of $15000, but rents are high in LA.

    Need­less to say, I won’t call them back.

  10. Monique Bryher | May 12, 2005 at 9:30 am | Permalink

    I’m sup­posed to be inter­viewed by these people on Monday (my busi­ness is in L.A.). I’m sort of the mind, like oth­ers, to just play along and see what hap­pens but not to give them the $15k. That money could be bet­ter spent else­where. I also ser­i­ously doubt that Shat­ner has any­thing much to do with this pro­duc­tion, or his web­site would prob­ably say he does. This is just prob­ably a mar­ket­ing tool to get us to pay for the pro­gram­ming so the pro­du­cers can air their show.

    Best,

    Monique

  11. Marcy | May 12, 2005 at 10:58 am | Permalink

    An asso­ci­ate pro­du­cer (sales per­son) came to our com­pany yes­ter­day. Ben did not have much of a sales pitch but he did talk about his girl­friend and later his wife…hmmm. It seemed straight­for­ward, “they” just wanted to help small busi­nesses grow, and for a frac­tion of the cost, you would get a TV pro­gram intro­duced by Wil­liam Shat­ner, whose name and image you could then use in per­petu­ity. How­ever, the hard close really tipped us off. Why do you need $5K down pay­ment today? What is wrong with sign­ing up tomor­row, next week or now that I think about it, never.

  12. Louis | May 20, 2005 at 8:43 am | Permalink

    I met with Ben Ham­mer yes­ter­day fol­low­ing a cold call from the folks at “Keep­ing Amer­ica Strong”. After the usual sales pitch exper­i­enced by the posts before mine, my research has tought me the following.

    The Keep­ing Amer­ica Strong is a video pro­duc­tion com­pany in the busi­ness of selling video ser­vices. If you are in the mar­ket you can find many such like ser­vices for hire at price points simil­iar to 15K they charge. In Clai­for­nia, there is no short­age of com­pan­ies pan­der­ing to new busi­ness own­ers usine retired politi­cian, cel­eb­raties and the like. Keep­ing Amer­ica Strong has a decent (in my opin­ion) oper­a­tion, but I do not appre­ci­ate the dcept­ive sales pitch. I was also con­cerned about the fact that i could not get any former cli­ents to return my calls regard­ing their exper­i­ences and success/failure with this product.

    I teach busi­ness, sales and lead­er­ship and offer free busi­ness train­ing to all vet­er­ans of the mil­it­ary (I am a retired Army Mas­ter Ser­geant). I star­ted 2 com­pan­ies, Lead­ers Advant­age (Web address the same) and the North­east Vet­er­ans Busi­ness Resource Cen­ter, http://www.NEVBRC.org, a non-profit that teaches vet­er­ans how to run and grow their own busi­nesses and I am a SCORE coun­selor with the Boston SCORE chapter.

    I would be happy to dis­cuss my exper­i­ence regard­ing this in fur­ther detail if you are inter­ested or con­cerned. LCelli@LeadersAdvantage.com

    Good luck.

  13. David Arnold | May 26, 2005 at 2:51 pm | Permalink

    Happy for this blog, now I don’t have to return this very strange call..

  14. Walter Smilinet | Jun 09, 2005 at 2:16 pm | Permalink

    I met with a rep­res­ent­at­ive in San Fran­cisco, while I could not afford the fee since I’m a small busi­ness owner, if I had it I’d pay 15,000 to have Shat­ner pro­mote my com­pany! Heck they paid Tiger Wood like 50 mil­lion to step out of a Buick. Ah Hollywood.

  15. simon thierry | Jun 09, 2005 at 2:43 pm | Permalink

    I was approached by an asso­ci­ate pro­du­cer 3 weeks ago regard­ing thsi show. I have to admit to being highly skep­tical at first given that there are numer­ous scams out there, but as our con­ver­sa­tion kept going I found the per­son to be not a pushy sales/telemarketer, but rather someone try­ing to find out whether he could jus­tify sendig a pro­du­cer to meet with me, and the determ­in­ing factor was whether my busi­ness would bene­fit from it or not. I was intrigued enough to set the appoint­ment, and the pro­du­cer came to visit just this past monday. his present­a­tion was not high pres­sure “sign on the doted line” kind of approach, but rather explain­ing the concept of the show and its pur­pose. I had pre­vi­ously vis­ited their web­site and took the liberty of research­ing some of the com­pan­ies men­tioned there, two did con­tact me and what they said is that their exper­i­ence was quite inter­est­ing and everything was done as they were told, there was a stu­dio inter­view, someone went to their loc­a­tion to tape a seg­ment, and it did air on TV, but the value of the show accord­ing to the people I con­tac­ted was on the CD and video mater­ial they get to use for their mar­ket­ing. to make a long story short, I did not find any­thing fishy about them, their present­a­tion was inter­est­ing, but in the end I felt my product was not ready to be mar­keted yet and there­fore be able to the keep­ing amer­ica strong series to my advant­age. sur­pris­ingly the pro­du­cer agreed, did not push me and wished me the best. you know in todays world we all have had some kind of bad exper­i­ence with someone try­ing to take advant­age, this was not one of them.

  16. Daniel | Jun 10, 2005 at 11:46 am | Permalink

    I was kind of skep­tical myslef. Comeon a TV star and net­work anchors for 15K. I thought it soun­ded too good to be true and I was really sus­pi­cious. But I checked their sight and looked at what they do. I know this is crazy but these guys a legit. I have heard of upteen groups doing this, but these boys seem to me the real deal. Call me naive, I don’t care but that is what I think. Now 15K no way, I don’t have it. But I think if a guy got some cash and is look­ing to get a jump on the com­pet­i­tion without the scam of infomer­cials hey this could be what the doc­tor ordered. Later.

  17. Lauren Wood | Jun 10, 2005 at 2:03 pm | Permalink

    Just so people read­ing this site know — the last three com­ments (from “Daniel”, “Simon”, and “Wal­ter”) all came from the same IP address — which makes me some­what sus­pi­cious! Not (yet) sus­pi­cious enough to delete the com­ments, but I may change my mind on that.

  18. Big Al | Jun 21, 2005 at 1:00 pm | Permalink

    We got a call from the “Keep­ing Amer­ica Strong” people yes­ter­day. Like most every­body else here, I had never heard of them before, so I decided to do a little Googling.

    First I went to their web­site and looked at the sample videos. It seems that Wil­liam Shat­ner just does some gen­eric “bookend” intros and extros for the show. Much of the inter­view­ing seems to be done by Doug Llewelyn (Mr. People’s Court reporter him­self… Woo­hoo!). There were also some “news anchor” types in there, and some­thing about it just screamed “Inform­er­cial!” to me.

    I looked up the Amer­ic­an­Life TV Net­work, and it does indeed exist. Its web­site can be found at http://www.goodtv.com . They seem to be a minor cable TV net­work (Dir­ecTV does not carry them, as far as I know) that shows mainly reruns of whole­some com­ed­ies and dra­mas, with some pub­lic interest pro­gram­ming thrown in. It actu­ally looks like a chan­nel I would enjoy watch­ing every once in a while.

    How­ever, I saw no men­tion of “Keep­ing Amer­ica Strong”, though there did seem to be slots around 5:00 am for “Paid Com­mer­cial Pro­gram­ming”. Some­thing tells me this is where the show would fit in.

    So as far as I can tell, this seems to be a video pro­duc­tion com­pany that will inter­view you for your own infomer­cial for $15,000. I am guess­ing they pay Amer­ic­an­Life to show your epis­ode once, and then they let you keep the video (or parts of it) for your own use at con­ven­tions, expos, etc. Not really sure how effect­ive this would be as a marketing/PR tool, but I sup­pose that would be up to each indi­vidual company.

    But $15,000? With Wil­liam Shat­ner involved, I would like to think that I could “Name My Own Price”™! :D

  19. stan pope | Jun 22, 2005 at 12:46 pm | Permalink

    I saw some com­ments on you web Blog that came from people who obvi­ously had no real exper­i­ence with the program..and i thought I’d add a statement,from someone who was on the Keep­ing Amer­ica Strong Show…my com­pany
    helped mar­ket a pion­eer­ing med­ical device related to heart and body scanning..and the keep­ing Ammer­ica Strong Show,created for usus­ing great celebrit­ies helped us to attract investors ‚raise the needed dollars„and helped us sig­ni­fic­antly ot mar­ket our centers„through the country..they helped us achive the cred­ib­il­ity we needed ‚and w feel they are doing great things..if you wish ffur­ther infoyou can con­tact me by email..popestan@yahoo.com

  20. Big Al | Jun 22, 2005 at 4:38 pm | Permalink

    Some­body with firsthand exper­i­ence, great! Stan, can you share with us your exper­i­ences with the show? What was it like? Would it be fair to say that you get a pro­fes­sion­ally pro­duced inter­view, which you could then use to mar­ket your com­pany? I sup­pose you and the pro­du­cers sat down to dis­cuss what types of things would be inter­viewed, etc.?

    Once you did the intervew, *how* did you use it to help pro­mote your busi­ness? For example, did you get a videotape/DVD with the inter­view that you could show to cli­ents and investors? Was it some­thing you would use as an intro­duc­tion to a present­a­tion, for example? Some­thing you would mail to them? etc.?

    Your com­ments on this blog would be appre­ci­ated, as it would help pro­mote a dia­log about this com­pany, as opposed to hav­ing a bunch of people “guess” as to what is going on. Thanks.

  21. Carol | Jul 06, 2005 at 3:17 pm | Permalink

    I was con­tac­ted by phone to set up an inter­view with a pro­du­cer local to my area. Because I was leav­ing town on an exten­ded trip, we set the appoint­ment for two weeks out. When I asked for a con­tact num­ber, in the event my trip was pro­longed, or that for some reason I had to post­pone, I was told that would not be necessary-THEY would con­tact ME to confirm.

    As it turned out, I came back ill, and waited for a phone call or email from them to res­ched­ule, but heard noth­ing. After I made an an appoint­ment with a doc­tor for the fol­low­ing day, the day of the inter­view, I received a fax con­firm­a­tion, but there was no phone num­ber or email address to which I could respond; I found this quite cir­cum­spect and very irritating.

    The pro­du­cer called the day of the appoint­ment to get dir­ec­tions and was sur­prised to hear that I did not receive his fax until late in the day prior to our meet­ing. We res­ched­uled. He was vey nice, sorry to hear about my ill­ness. In the mean­time, I researched the pro­gram every way I could, speak­ing to sev­eral people I found on the web that had bought into it and read­ing everything I could find.

    When the pro­du­cer arrived and made his present­a­tion, there was noth­ing on the video I had not already seen on other par­ti­cipants’ web sites or else­where on the inter­net. But I had many ques­tions. The first ques­tion was, “You chose my com­pany at ran­dom for this pres­ti­gi­ous expos­ure, but what do you know about me, my pro­fes­sional back­ground, the repu­ta­tion of my com­pany, its fin­an­cials, etc., and why would Wil­liam Shat­ner want to put his name on a product, ser­vice, or indi­vidual of which and whom he knows noth­ing? That is an unne­ces­sary risk that someone in Mr. Shatner’s pos­i­tion need not take.”

    The pro­du­cer replied that I had a legit­im­ate ques­tion, and explained that IF my com­pany was selec­ted, the show attor­neys would con­duct an in-depth invest­ig­a­tion on me and my com­pany. OK. Back­wards, but OK.

    To make a long story short, I am con­vinced that “Keep­ing Amer­ica Strong” is a legit­am­ate mar­ket­ing pro­gram. I do not believe it is non-profit, as my research and tele­phone con­ver­sa­tions with oth­ers indic­ate that the pro­duc­tion com­pany involved makes money on the deal, though an amount in keep­ing with what one would expect to pro­duce these types of mar­ket­ing tools– CD Rom busi­ness cards, videos, DVD’s.

    I did not buy into the pro­gram for these reas­ons:
    1) I did not like the mys­tery of who was going to inter­view me and the fact I was not per­mit­ted to have any con­tact inform­a­tion for my inter­view­ing pro­du­cer.
    2) They expec­ted my ego to play a big part in my buy­ing in, say­ing how dif­fer­ent, inter­est­ing, etc. were my ser­vices. There are thou­sands out there who do what what I do, so the fact they could not sub­stan­ti­ate the basis for their intense interest told me that their only interest was my $15,000.
    3) The part where you have only the next few days to plunk down $5K as your down pay­ment while you are being “approved” is an old sales tac­tic to close the deal, and it turned me off. I was told that if I did not com­mit to a $15K invest­ment within the next day or two, my oppor­tun­ity to do so was gone forever. The pitch here was that Mr. Shat­ner agreed to brand this pro­gram with his name up until June 1. After that date, it would take a spe­cial con­ces­sion to “get in under the wire” at that price, because soon, the price would be raised to six fig­ures– clearly not an option for small busi­ness own­ers.
    4) This kind of mar­ket­ing is not a good fit for my ser­vices. Foot­age would be bor­ing, and I could bet­ter spend my mar­ket­ing dol­lars else­where.
    5) While I am quite sure this is a legit deal, I was turned off by their clos­ing tac­tics and other busi­ness prac­tices that totally insul­ted my intelligence.

    Wil­liam Shatner’s endorse­ment, your inter­view being aired all over the coun­try (but at what times and on what sta­tions are anybody’s guess), a day in the stu­dio work­ing with a team of pro­du­cers, make-up artists, etc… all pretty heady stuff, but only worth the invest­ment if you can over­look the hard sell and jus­tify the exact use of the mater­i­als being produced.

  22. Robert | Jul 27, 2005 at 1:37 pm | Permalink

    I was called by Keep­ing Amer­ica Strong. I admit I was intrigued. We arranged for an asso­ci­ate pro­du­cer to meet with my team and me at our company.

    I appre­ci­ate that they seem to go out of their way to cre­ate a great mar­ket­ing video pack­age, but their pitch is odd, and if they are legit­im­ate why the song and dance? Let’s be prac­tical and review the oppor­tun­ity to see if it sounds too good to be true: stu­dio time at ABC stu­dios, brand align­ment with Mr. Shat­ner et al, retained repro­duc­tion rights, three edited ver­sions for our use any way that we please, and for $15,000 (com­mon). Look at it another way: why would an early stage com­pany pay des­per­ately needed work­ing cap­ital to be inter­viewed by people from a TV show on a cable chan­nel no one can find?
    When someone finds the net­work http://www.goodtv.com (thank you Big Al) you can’t even find the show? Besides, if Mr. Shat­ner is waiv­ing fees why the hard sell? His name would cer­tainly carry an oppor­tun­ity like this.

    Much, if not all, of the “turn-off” sales tac­tics men­tioned in this blog were used. I agree that their pitch does rely on a heavy dose of one’s ego to buy in. How­ever, ego is a strong word. How about just *desire*. All of us striv­ing to launch a new com­pany that would help “keep Amer­ica strong” do so with a desire to be suc­cess­ful. Their pitch feeds on that. I did not appre­ci­ate it no mat­ter how legit their scheme appears to be.

    While we are on the sub­ject of *legit* why all of the mys­tery? The asso­ci­ate pro­du­cer that met with us could not tell us why we were selec­ted, or how their selec­tion team found us. He didn’t want to leave the DVD that he showed to us (with con­tent match­ing what is on their web­site, hmm). He did not want to leave his bro­chure, which was obvi­ously designed to be left with poten­tial cli­ents. On both sub­jects he said not until you have been *selec­ted* can I give you this inform­a­tion. He acqui­esced and left the bro­chure, but asked me to mail it back to him if we were not selec­ted. At this point I felt like he was reluct­ant to leave any evid­ence of a scam behind. The hard sell then commenced.

    The asso­ci­ate pro­du­cer showed us a simplistic, vague, and ambigu­ous con­tract (cer­tainly not one that a major pro­duc­tion com­pany would issue). There was a term per­tain­ing to a celebrity fee that could be waived (don’t recall actual lan­guage). This is where I think they are scam­ming to a degree. They were upfront about the $15,000 fee, but they were not upfront about how to find their show on TV, or about the cel­eb­rat­ing fee waiv­ing busi­ness until after they wasted our time and asked for $5,000 up front. At this point we decided to pass. While our tech­no­logy sup­ports the auto­mobile industry we have also been car deal­ers for dec­ades. We know hard sell, soft sell, and everything in between. The asso­ci­ate pro­du­cer went so far as to try to call Mr. Bert Tenser from my office (the exec­ut­ive pro­du­cer of the show) to obtain approval to waive Mr. Shatner’s fee. He did not reach him. Mr. Tenser I don’t need any favors. What I need is a level of pro­fes­sion­al­ism worthy of being paid.

    If they are legit — how do they make money? The people that they claim are involved don’t work for free. I would not expect them to espe­cially Mr. Shat­ner at this point in his great career. Besides, if Mr. Shat­ner were “donat­ing” his time for the bene­fit of early stage com­pan­ies you would think that he would men­tion this per­son­ally. If they want some stock in our fledgling com­pany and fees paid their pitch would be more beleavable. After all Mr. Shat­ner exper­i­enced a wind fall income from his early, and con­tin­ued, involve­ment with PriceLine.com. How­ever, a flat $15,850 just sounds too good to be true, I will pass.

    If someone has had a good exper­i­ence with their ser­vice I would like to hear about it at info@vnscorporation.com

  23. TJIC | Jul 28, 2005 at 11:44 am | Permalink

    I just received a phone call from them, googled on the pro­gram name, found your blog, read the post (all while still “talk­ing” with the sales per­son), and was able to blow them off post-haste.

    Thanks for the info!

  24. bob | Sep 19, 2005 at 11:16 am | Permalink

    I just got a call from these people today. At first it soun­ded believ­able but then I went to Google the name of the show and Shat­ner and thank god I found this blog. Now I can for­get about being on TV. :(

  25. Scott | Sep 19, 2005 at 12:11 pm | Permalink

    Just got called today. Not inter­ested, but (like Bob above) me, Google led me here. Now I’m really not inter­ested. :)

    –Scott

  26. stan pope | Sep 23, 2005 at 3:03 pm | Permalink

    it star­ted with a call accept­ing us, and then a pack­age about how the pro­cess would work, and how to best pre­pare for my tele­vi­sion inter­view arrived.
    As instruc­ted I wrote out a series of ques­tion for their anchor a man named Doug Llewlyn, who I remembered from his insight­ful cov­er­age of the OJ Simpson trial. He also seemed to be a man who was good at help­ing aver­age Joe’s and Jane’s look good on TV. Even if they’d just embar­rassed the heck out of them­selves in front of Judge Wapner on the People’s Court. GREAT SHOW!!!
    I worked in the months prior to the tap­ing with a head pro­duc­tion guy named Ramdo Sikoly dis­cuss­ing the edit of my thirty minute tele­vi­sion show—and the three parts that would ulti­mately end up on busi­ness card CD-Roms and three dif­fer­ent videos and con­tent for our web­site.
    Then the big day came and I arrived at the ABC Stu­dios and had an awe­some steak din­ner with the owner and Mr. Lylewn and we talked and joked and posi­tioned my com­pany for the tap­ing, and the funny thing was a lot of that chit chat really paid off because I was com­fort­able talk­ing with Mr. Llylewn dur­ing the inter­view and even joked a little and it seemed Well Al, I decided to sub­mit my com­pany and soon after received a tele­phone call to say things were going really well.
    About two days later another pro­duc­tion guy Scott Zegner called to set up a B-Roll,which was just shots of my busi­ness to inter-cut with the stu­dio stuff. A really great cam­era guy came to my offices, Mort Basest.
    About a week and a half later I got a let­ter from Sikoly that the show would air on TV, and maybe the next day the videos and cd busi­ness cards arrived, and man! the show really cap­tured what we do.
    We then took the tapes to sev­eral VC meet­ings and gave them to our sales reps. To make a long story short. I got a nice sized VC invest­ment and star­ted mak­ing some decent sales. Wil­liam Shat­ner cer­tainly opens doors that were closed to us before the show, no won­der he got mil­lions from Priceline…. Any­way we used the videos to help sell the com­pany which went very, very well. I can hon­estly say it was totally worth 10 times the amount at the very least. If you’re think­ing of doing the show, I’d say go for it. I don’t know what you do but as a health and test­ing com­pany the show put us on the map in a big way.

  27. Savage Source | Sep 27, 2005 at 4:31 pm | Permalink

    So these people called my sec­ret­ary today, and after a little google-ing around I have to say– IS SHATNER SO HARD UP FOR CASH THAT HE HAS TO STOOP TO THIS LEVEL. Small busi­ness own­ers beware-IF IT SOUNDS TO GOOD TO BE TRUE.….IT IS! I think I’ll just stick with ADwords and CPC’s, thanks. I mean $15k! For that kind of money I could have first line first page!! Thank God for blogs, or I too could have been the next con­test­ant to “come on down”. Oh and by the way, visit my site and BUY some­thing why don’t ya!?

  28. Gabor | Oct 01, 2005 at 2:59 pm | Permalink

    We were “inter­viewed” by a field pro­du­cer a few days ago, and we even gave them check (less than $5000). I woke up this morn­ing in a cold sweat obvi­ously dream­ing about it, so I decided to do some invest­ig­a­tion and found this blog. For a moment in the morn­ing I thought this was a com­plete fraud. Return­ing to the “inter­view”, I even talked to Mr. Ten­zer on the phone (while the field pro­du­cer was there, hope­fully it was him) who is a very pleas­ant man. So was the field pro­du­cer. I backed out of the deal this morn­ing for two reas­ons:
    1. The pres­sure was on because Mr.Shatner might demand fees as of Septem­ber 1st, which of course was waived. We sus­pec­ted that this was a lie.
    2. The TV chan­nel does not show this pro­gram­ming except some paid pro­gram­ming at 3 am in the morn­ing, which might be it. So I think the pub­li­city is not there, which was the main reason we signed on. We want to reach indi­vidu­als with their own ten­nis courts or people who are look­ing for products like ours and baby boomers are a good cat­egory.
    I think the com­pany is legit and they do what they prom­ise except #2 the above points. The DVD and tape I am sure are done pro­fes­sion­ally, but I am not sure it would do us much good for the $16,000 we would spend. We could use it as work­ing cap­ital.
    What I don’t under­stand is why some prom­in­ent people are involved in this, even if they make some money, and use gim­micks to close the deal. In the age of the Inter­net these tac­tics will back­fire. If everything were 100% true we might have done it, but these little false­hoods made us uneasy and we felt we were taken advant­age of. Bad move on their part. What about just present­ing this as a busi­ness pro­pos­i­tion and for­get about being “selec­ted” and all that BS. Maybe more people would buy in because the BS would not raise the red flag in our minds.

  29. Marty Baeur | Oct 02, 2005 at 7:09 am | Permalink

    We respect what you are try­ing to do in bring­ing proper inform­a­tion to people. How­ever, in going through your blog we see that the bulk of the inform­a­tion is from people who have had only had some kind of verbal con­ver­sa­tions, mostly on the tele­phone and have NEVER BEEN ACCEPTED FOR THE KEEPING AMERICA STRONG PROGRAM, and have never gone through the actual steps and pro­ced­ures and most import­antly never exper­i­enced the bene­fits. We have helped over 500 com­pan­ies nation­wide with this pro­gram and we feel that is there is an inde­pend­ent web­site that gives inform­a­tion about it that at the very least it should reveal the facts about what the pro­gram actu­ally does. For this reason our vice pres­id­ent sent sev­eral times inform­a­tion to you that rev­els what hap­pens with those who go through pro­gram. IN the event that it some­how never got to you I’m send­ing another copy. To the bene­fit of all con­cerned we appre­ci­ate you put­ting the blog up on the net. If for any reason you should refused to post this com­ment we would like an explan­a­tion to news@heartbeatofamerica.tv

    Please register your mobile phone to activ­ate this fea­ture.
    Register your phone to receive a text mes­sage when you receive Mail from par­tic­u­lar senders.

    Pre­vi­ous | Next | Back to Mes­sages Print­able View — Full Head­ers
    DeleteReply­For­ward­Spam­Move…
    This mes­sage is not flagged. [ Flag Mes­sage — Mark as Unread ]

    Date: Fri, 30 Sep 2005 14:29:40 –0700 (PDT)
    From: “annber usa” Add to Address Book Add Mobile Alert
    Yahoo! Domain­Keys has con­firmed that this mes­sage was sent by yahoo.com. Learn more
    Sub­ject: Fwd: blog post inform­a­tion
    To: mblookhere@yahoo.com

    Note: for­war­ded mes­sage attached.

    For­war­ded Mes­sage [ Down­load File | Save to Yahoo! Briefcase ]

    From: news@heartbeatofamerica.tv
    To: annberproductions@yahoo.com
    Sub­ject: blog post inform­a­tion
    Date: Tue, 16 Aug 2005 13:13:02 –0700

    HTML Attach­ment [ Down­load File | Save to Yahoo! Briefcase ]

    http://www.laurenwood.org/anyway/archives/2005/03/10/keeping-america-strong/

    My name is Bern­ard I joined the Keep­ing Amer­ica Strong pro­gram two and a half years ago as Senior Pro­du­cer. I joined the organ­iz­a­tion because I saw that Keep­ing Amer­ica Strong is doing import­ant things for the entre­pren­eurs of Amer­ica by giv­ing them the cred­ib­il­ity of celebrity icon names and images that only the giants of industry could nor­mally afford. I saw how com­pan­ies were suc­ceed­ing from every­where includ­ing Canada, Venezuela China, the USA and how they felt honored to be a part of the pro­gram. I also saw how they had all of the rights to use the icon images on videos and CD’s that were edited down from the tele­vi­sion show and tar­geted to their pro­spect­ive cli­ents. I felt good about it then and even feel bet­ter about it today. Every pro­gram has doubters no mat­ter how good but without pre­ju­dice I will tell any­one that this is real and sup­por­ted by fam­ous people of the gov­ern­ment, the media, and the enter­tain­ment world who truly care. The actual 30 minute show airs nation­ally on the Amer­ica Life Tele­vi­sion Net­work at 9:00 am EST, it is not on in all areas, con­sult your local cable pro­vider to see if Amer­ican Life is in your area. While it may be glam­or­ous to be on a national show, I would say that the main bene­fit to the com­pan­ies lies in the Videos and CD that come from the show that are tar­geted to pro­spect­ive cli­ents. If you would like to get any fur­ther facts instead of the could be’s and should be’s feel free to con­tact me at 310–607-8380

  30. Marty Baeur | Oct 02, 2005 at 7:11 am | Permalink

    We respect what you are try­ing to do in bring­ing proper inform­a­tion to people. How­ever, in going through your blog we see that the bulk of the inform­a­tion is from people who have had only had some kind of verbal con­ver­sa­tions, mostly on the tele­phone and have NEVER BEEN ACCEPTED FOR THE KEEPING AMERICA STRONG PROGRAM, and have never gone through the actual steps and pro­ced­ures and most import­antly never exper­i­enced the bene­fits. We have helped over 500 com­pan­ies nation­wide with this pro­gram and we feel that is there is an inde­pend­ent web­site that gives inform­a­tion about it that at the very least it should reveal the facts about what the pro­gram actu­ally does. For this reason our vice pres­id­ent sent sev­eral times inform­a­tion to you that rev­els what hap­pens with those who go through pro­gram. IN the event that it some­how never got to you I’m send­ing another copy. To the bene­fit of all con­cerned we appre­ci­ate you put­ting the blog up on the net. If for any reason you should refused to post this com­ment we would like an explan­a­tion to news@heartbeatofamerica.tv

    My name is Bern­ard I joined the Keep­ing Amer­ica Strong pro­gram two and a half years ago as Senior Pro­du­cer. I joined the organ­iz­a­tion because I saw that Keep­ing Amer­ica Strong is doing import­ant things for the entre­pren­eurs of Amer­ica by giv­ing them the cred­ib­il­ity of celebrity icon names and images that only the giants of industry could nor­mally afford. I saw how com­pan­ies were suc­ceed­ing from every­where includ­ing Canada, Venezuela China, the USA and how they felt honored to be a part of the pro­gram. I also saw how they had all of the rights to use the icon images on videos and CD’s that were edited down from the tele­vi­sion show and tar­geted to their pro­spect­ive cli­ents. I felt good about it then and even feel bet­ter about it today. Every pro­gram has doubters no mat­ter how good but without pre­ju­dice I will tell any­one that this is real and sup­por­ted by fam­ous people of the gov­ern­ment, the media, and the enter­tain­ment world who truly care. The actual 30 minute show airs nation­ally on the Amer­ica Life Tele­vi­sion Net­work at 9:00 am EST, it is not on in all areas, con­sult your local cable pro­vider to see if Amer­ican Life is in your area. While it may be glam­or­ous to be on a national show, I would say that the main bene­fit to the com­pan­ies lies in the Videos and CD that come from the show that are tar­geted to pro­spect­ive cli­ents. If you would like to get any fur­ther facts instead of the could be’s and should be’s feel free to con­tact me at 310–607-8380

  31. Lauren Wood | Oct 02, 2005 at 9:15 am | Permalink

    I’m glad someone from the pro­gram finally respon­ded (and con­trary to what he wrote, it’s the first time any­one from the show ever actu­ally sent me inform­a­tion about it for this blog after I wrote the ini­tial post). Since I now have com­ments from some who turned it down, some who par­ti­cip­ated, and some who are oth­er­wise involved, read­ers can draw their own conclusions.

  32. carol | Oct 06, 2005 at 12:06 pm | Permalink

    I worked for the com­pany, and I ques­tion their hon­esty and integ­rity???? … I came,…I saw.…I left?**&^…the con­cerns I read are also my con­cerns plus more???

  33. Howard Montaque | Oct 06, 2005 at 12:39 pm | Permalink

    I was just called and reseached to find this blog. I have only returned the phone call and left a mes­sage. There is no way I can afford $15,000 as I am work­ing here in Afgh­anistan to help pay for my com­pany. My wife and I are work­ing hard at build­ing our per­sonal and busi­ness credit to try for a loan. $15,000 in my pocket right now would surely go to put­ting more money into my com­pany. I have a GREAT story but you wont hear it on this show. Does any­one have inform­a­tion on busi­ness loans for a start up com­pany with less than aver­age credit? If you got a busi­ness loan how did you do it and through whom? PLEASE email me. I would love to be back home instead of here in the desert. howardqent@yahoo.com

  34. Anonymous | Oct 12, 2005 at 7:56 pm | Permalink

    I used to work for this com­pany as an “AP”. DO NOT go with this com­pany or give them your money!!!

  35. Paul | Oct 12, 2005 at 8:13 pm | Permalink

    PEOPLE!!! I used to work for this com­pany and I will TELL you what goes on:

    They pay whomever they can get to cold call off a bunch of lists…they didn’t “get your name” because they were impressed with you…they are call­ing EVERYONE they can get to cut them a check for $15,000.00. They have lists upon lists of pro­spect­ive people to cold call and soli­cit to. They are no dif­fer­ent from every­one else that cold calls your office try­ing to solicit…

    The people who actu­ally run this office are so far from pro­fes­sional its not even funny. They are unbe­liev­ably incom­pet­ent, have little to no integ­rity, are hell-bent on com­mis­sions. If you SAW this office or even really SPOKE with these people, you would not even CONSIDER giv­ing them your money. The “Field Pro­du­cer” gives the same sales-oriented speech to every­one. You’re not spe­cial, trust me.

    DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY ON THIS CRAP!!!! YOU WILL REGRET IT!!!!

  36. Dan S. | Oct 13, 2005 at 12:08 pm | Permalink

    I just had these idi­ots call me and when I asked “how much” they hung up on me. I can smell a scam a thou­sand miles away. It reminds me of another scam going around that was air­ing on Chan­nel 6 (real estate channel)in L.A. a few years back. I think the name of that show was made in Amer­ica or some­thing like that.
    Run as fast as you can from these idiots.

  37. Dan S. | Oct 13, 2005 at 12:20 pm | Permalink

    Now I remem­ber. It is Heart­beat of Amer­ica that is behinh this scam. They came to my office a few years ago. These Idi­ots are work­ing out of a lettle office in Malibu. Here is their con­tact info.
    But don’t call them unless you want to be scammed.

    Heart­beat Of Amer­ica Pro­duc­tion Department

    22761 Pacific Coast Hwy
    Suite 104
    Malibu,CA 90265

    Toll Free Telephone:(800) 956‑1787
    Fax Num­ber: (310) 317– 0098
    E-Mail: news@heartbeatofamerica.tv

    Con­tact: Scott Ten­zer (Pro­duc­tion Manager

  38. Kevin | Oct 18, 2005 at 3:20 pm | Permalink

    They tar­get small busi­nesses a lot. Its so awful! These poor people are lead to believe that they are mak­ing a wise invest­ment that will cause their busi­ness to grow like noth­ing else and in many cases will spend all the money they have ($15,000 is a lot of money for any­one!) It is a huge scam that costs inno­cent people a lot of money and I hope word gets out to as many people as possible!!

    These people must have the WORST karma!!

  39. Lauren Wood | Oct 21, 2005 at 7:52 pm | Permalink

    Just so people know — the com­ments from “Anonym­ous”, “Paul”, and “Kevin” all come from the same IP address, which I find sus­pi­cious. The com­pany Heart­beat of Amer­ica left me a mes­sage to state that they have never employed any­one named Paul. Since I have no way of veri­fy­ing any­thing that any­body writes on my blog, and no way of know­ing who com­menters are (IP address is not suf­fi­cient to identify people), I’d like to remind people that I also have no way of veri­fy­ing the accur­acy or oth­er­wise of any state­ments made by oth­ers on this blog.

  40. Kevin | Oct 29, 2005 at 12:18 pm | Permalink

    ATTENTION!!

    We are not using our real names. If you were going to tell the truth about the com­pany you worked for, neither would you. Espe­cially if you knew what kind of people they were (some can just be real jerks).

    Anonym­ous and Kevin are both me, and no I am not using my real name. “Paul” isn’t using his real name either.

    Want proof?? Here is the num­ber to the job hot­line! Cal yourself!

    You can dis­credit us if you want to…but I can verify all the inform­a­tion and everything that has been said to you as well as little things you can ask them. How would any­one who did not work there be able to do that??

    If the people who worked there are will­ing to speak out agains them that should be a BIG red flag!! And since we are not the only ones, it is not pos­sible that all of us were fired or some­thing! We just want people to know that is it a scam that will not give you the res­ults you want.

    Each of the cold callers (Called “AP“s for Asso­ci­ate Pro­du­cer) that call you stand to make half a thou­sand and every­one else stands to make quite a bit too (and you had bet­ter believe the field pro­du­cers do!)if the field pro­du­cers are able to extract money from you for the show. The people that work there (and they always need new people) are lured there by a craigslist ad in the Los Angeles area prom­ising them the pos­sib­il­ity of thou­sands of dol­lars a week. (Few of you will as you will soon see-to all you hope­ful people!)

    Your con­cerns are legit…can YOU find the Good Life Net­work on your chan­nel sta­tion?? Chances are no. It’s an infomer­cial on a chan­nel that no one will ever see no mat­ter what they tell you. And those little cds and crap are NOT worth $15,000 and will prob­ably not help you much.

    And any­one can get them done, there is no real qual­i­fy­ing, that’s just a sales tech­nique called the “take away”. (A les­son for you for ANYONE that cold calls your office).

    This is not a non-profit organ­iz­a­tion, and if you dir­ectly ask them they have to leg­ally admit that they do not claim to NOT make a profit. We are just telling you where that profit goes– they’re pocket! Not to sav­ing America.

    We just feel it is REALLY WRONG for these people to use 9–11 in their sales pitch when they are not even help­ing Amer­ica much but them­selves, that’s what got us the worst! (they might not now, watch! But there are plenty of other com­ment­ary above that backs that up, so if they don’t, just know they did). Per­haps they have no REGARD OR RESPECT for the people who died and what that really meant for our coun­try to use that to fur­ther their own money-making when it is not even a non-profit organ­iz­a­tion!! For shame!!

    The office is very small and on the PCH high­way. They stuff a lot of callers (“AP“s) into it and a few of the “pro­du­cers” who are basic­ally people they can find that are cor­rupt enough to be loyal (and they do not make calls). We under­stand it’s a tough eco­nomy, but damn.

    Here is the ad they are cur­rently using on Craigslist in LA to recruit new callers:

    (look for your­self and make your own call. You can search it for your­self under Craigslist in LA before they change it! And the fact they call themeselves “among the lead­ers in the industry” is the fun­ni­est thing to any­one who will even inter­view there. It has to be the biggest lie in the world):

    PLEASE FIRST CALL OUR JOB HOTLINE 310–607-8383!

    We are among the lead­ers in the tele­vi­sion and motion pic­ture industry. We are cur­rently using the power of major super­stars to pro­mote emer­ging busi­nesses on our 30 minute national busi­ness TV show. We are look­ing for intel­li­gent, well-spoken appoint­ment set­ters who are will­ing to make a large volume of calls to set up meet­ings with Pres­id­ents and CEOs regard­ing a pos­sible inter­view on our show. You will be work­ing out of our office in Malibu, CA.

    The pos­i­tion pays a base salary plus a com­mis­sion of $500 per appoint­ment you set, which res­ults in a closed deal/show. This can eas­ily equal $900-$1,400+ per week on aver­age. This is a full time job. Hours are Monday through Fri­day 8a.m. — 4p.m. SERIOUS APPLICANT, inter­ested in mak­ing a sub­stan­tial income we would love to talk to you.

    PLEASE FIRST CALL OUR JOB HOTLINE 310–607-8383!

  41. Kevin | Oct 29, 2005 at 12:46 pm | Permalink

    Once again (for all you people who are too lazy to read to the end)HERE IS THE AD ON CRAIGSLIST IN LA THEY USE TO RECRUIT THE VERY TELEMARKETERS THAT CALL YOU!! CALL IT YOURSELF!!!:

    PLEASE FIRST CALL OUR JOB HOTLINE 310–607-8383!

    We are among the lead­ers in the tele­vi­sion and motion pic­ture industry. We are cur­rently using the power of major super­stars to pro­mote emer­ging busi­nesses on our 30 minute national busi­ness TV show. We are look­ing for intel­li­gent, well-spoken appoint­ment set­ters who are will­ing to make a large volume of calls to set up meet­ings with Pres­id­ents and CEOs regard­ing a pos­sible inter­view on our show. You will be work­ing out of our office in Malibu, CA.

    The pos­i­tion pays a base salary plus a com­mis­sion of $500 per appoint­ment you set, which res­ults in a closed deal/show. This can eas­ily equal $900-$1,400+ per week on aver­age. This is a full time job. Hours are Monday through Fri­day 8a.m. — 4p.m. SERIOUS APPLICANT, inter­ested in mak­ing a sub­stan­tial income we would love to talk to you.

    PLEASE FIRST CALL OUR JOB HOTLINE 310–607-8383!

  42. michael firewalker | Nov 21, 2005 at 6:11 am | Permalink

    I am a former LA exec­ut­ive with Keep­ing Amer­ica Strong who presen­ted its pro­gram to com­pan­ies in the field, and I now live in beau­ti­ful San­oma, Ari­zona.  By acci­dent I ran across this blog and after read­ing it I find that most of it is the biggest insult and dis­grace I’ve ever seen and I just had to com­ment even though I’m no longer with Keep­ing Amer­ica Strong.  The posts I read are mostly writ­ten by people who received an isol­ated tele­phone call or claim they pre­vi­ously worked for the com­pany and give phony names and no iden­tity and no way to reach them and hide behind what might be some kind of hid­den agenda.  Now let me tell you the real world.
     
    First of all, a busi­ness that comes aboard becomes the fea­ture of a thirty minute national cable tele­vi­sion show with a copy for them to re-broadcast it loc­ally if they wish to.  But more import­antly they also receive the three dif­fer­ent videos, CD-Roms plus a web­site pro­duc­tion all edited from the tele­vi­sion show to approx­im­ately 10 minutes each and given to them to exclus­ively use in unlim­ited num­bers to tar­get their pro­spect­ive cli­ents who may miss the TV show.  Every one of these five pro­duc­tions includes Wil­liam Shat­ner, fam­ous net­work anchors, and an Admiral of the US Navy present­ing their story. Can any of you on this blog provide smal­ler com­pan­ies with celebrity Icons that they can asso­ci­ate with?  Could you provide these Icons who nor­mally receive mil­lions of dol­lars to par­ti­cip­ate for approx­im­ately $15,000?  Or bet­ter yet, could you do it for $100,000?  Or could you even do it for $500,000 or a mil­lion dol­lars?  If you are for real come out of your hid­ing place and con­tact me with the name of a giant tele­vi­sion, motion pic­ture, or ath­letic star that you could provide to small com­pan­ies to help them pro­mote their import­ance and cred­ib­il­ity, and tell me the dol­lars it would take. 
     
    Keep­ing Amer­ica Strong has done the impossible for hun­dreds of com­pan­ies nation­wide who are grate­ful and have sent their let­ters thank­ing Keep­ing Amer­ica Strong for the honor of present­ing them.  You who knock this pro­gram, what could you do to cre­ate five shows with giant stars and Icons and deliver them to a smal­ler com­pany for $15,850 instead of $500,000 to a mil­lion?
     
    Keep­ing Amer­ica Strong is for real and so am I and my name is Michael Fire­walker and you can reach me at Michael_firewalker@yahoo.com, I would really love it if you would step up to the plate, tell me who you are and where you can be reached and what you now think, and maybe we can end some of these scam com­ments and unjus­ti­fied insults and slanders that are on this blog.

  43. vt | Jan 25, 2006 at 7:28 am | Permalink

    I got a pol­ished call yes­ter­day (1/24/06) from these people using the same tac­tics described above.

    I checked the com­pany on the web and then found this blog. What really irks me is what they are will­ing to do to prey on des­per­ate small busi­ness owners.

    Anonym­ous

  44. Casey | Mar 02, 2006 at 11:45 am | Permalink

    I received a call yes­ter­day (3/1/06) from a girl claim­ing to be Wil­liam Shatner’s per­sonal assist­ant. Need­less to say I had some doubts as to whether Mr. Shatner’s per­sonal assist­ant would actu­ally be mak­ing cold calls to com­pan­ies. Thanks to Google, I found you. Now my boss won’t have to waste his time call­ing these people back. Thank you Lauren for keep­ing this blog up for those of us out there that have not heard of this scam before.

    What I find most inter­est­ing about this whole scheme is that they are giv­ing some awards (not sure how many) to par­ti­cipants of this show for “Keep­ing Amer­ica Strong”. Sure sounds like they should be giv­ing awards to par­ti­cipants for “Keep­ing The Show’s Pock­ets Full”.

  45. Larry Buckley | Mar 02, 2006 at 11:47 am | Permalink

    We just got back from our tap­ing at HD Broadcasting’s stu­dio in North Hol­ly­wood and I am glad I accep­ted the pro­posal prior to read­ing this bolg or else we may not have paticip­ated. Some of the neg­at­ive com­ments out­lined here are accur­ate but I beleive the bene­fits out­weigh these points. Let me explain.

    1) The point about being selec­ted because you are spe­cial, I beleive is false. I think any com­pany who is inter­viewed and wants to be selec­ted will indeed be selec­ted.
    2) We too had the phone inter­view with Bert Tenser who gives the impres­sion that Shatner’s fees are on a day to day basis and that we are just get­ting in under the wire. It seems like blogs going back to mid 05 say the same thing. After going through the pro­cess, it is not at all obvi­ous why they feel the need to place urgency on this point. After all this is just a con­trac­tual point to ensure that there are no hid­den charges after the fact.

    Given the above two points, I would like to address the pos­it­ives.
    1) We have a friend with prior exper­i­ence in TV pro­duc­tions and she advised that the $15850 was not at all unreas­on­able and that if you were to do this level of pro­fes­ison­al­ism, it would likely cost much more.
    2) Our pre-taping inter­view with Doug Llewelyn and Bert Tenser was very post­ive and we spent an hour tun­ing the types of ques­tions to put our story in the best pos­sible light. They took the time to really under­stand our busi­ness.
    3) The pro­duc­tion stu­dio was very pro­fes­sional and the actual inter­view gave us about 23 minutes of face time that included a 10 minute seg­ment about what it is that we do and the cus­tom­ers that we serve. This was fol­lowed by a, 8 minute seg­ment that dealt with alli­ances we have with other large com­pan­ies and we had invited a rep­res­ent­at­ive of one of the worlds lead­ing man­u­fac­tur­ers of per­sonal com­put­ing products to join us and help plug our comapny. HBA wel­comed them to the stu­dio to join us. A final 5 minute seg­ment dealth with our back­grounds and how we got to this point.

    Now the proof of the pud­ding will be in the res­ults which remain to be seen. The actual TV view­ing on Amer­ican Life TV is not what is import­ant for us. We want the video that we can stream on our web site as well as the CD/DVD that can be handed out at trade shows. Addi­tion­ally we want to be able to mass mail CDs to pro­spect­ive deal­ers who can see the endorse­ment value of Shat­ner as well as a high qual­ity, pro­fes­sion­ally pro­duced piece describ­ing our business.

    In con­clu­sion, $15850 is a big bite for many com­pan­ies but we believe it will be well worth the invest­ment. One final com­ment. We were at the stu­dio for around 6 hours. They staggered us with 3 other comapnies as we cycled through the vari­ous stages of the pro­cess. As we talked with these other com­pan­ies, we got the same reac­tion from them that we ourselves had felt.

  46. Brent S. | Mar 18, 2006 at 4:31 pm | Permalink

    Am I the only one? Or does this last com­ment sound like it came from someone who will bene­fit from your busi­ness? Why would someone want to say that other com­pan­ies felt the same way, sound­ing like a com­mer­cial, and oh yea it isn’t really the infomer­cial I want it is the stream­ing video and the cds which is what you are really pay­ing for and oh isn’t every­one there just so great! It just sounds fake. For­give me if I am wrong but hope­fully someone else here agrees. Just be cau­tious, all

  47. Jim Waide | Apr 12, 2006 at 12:41 pm | Permalink

    Well i got the same call as many of you from Keep Amer­ica Strong. My appoint­ment is in five days and I can’t wait to ask him ques­tions. Who ever these people are they did spend time mak­ing the two web­sites for their scam. I won­der if Wil­liam Shat­ner knows his name is being used for this scam? My busi­ness is in Phoenix and I won­der if they fly someone to Phoenix to give me the pitch? Their scam must be work­ing because they do spend money to make money. Funny thing they called my cel­lu­lar store to give me the pitch. Why would they call a cel­lu­lar store?
    Jim

  48. Paul Singh | Apr 20, 2006 at 9:10 pm | Permalink


    All people look­ing for inform­a­tion about Heart­beat of
    Amer­ica
    should know that it is a SCAM.

     I ini­tially received a call from these people about a month
    ago set­ting up an ‘inter­view’. At that time they men­tioned noth­ing about the
    com­pany ‘Keep­ing Amer­ica Strong’. I think the organ­iz­a­tion was forced to change
    the way they mar­keted the com­pany because of this blog.
     
    If you Google ‘Keep­ing Amer­ica Strong’ this site ranks as the second
    link – if you Google ‘Heart­beat of Amer­ica’ this site doesn’t come up in the
    first few pages. So I fig­ure we should help people find inform­a­tion.
     The web­site http://www.heartbeatofamerica.tv men­tions noth­ing
    about the cost of the ‘show’. The organ­iz­a­tion wasted my time — I am in the pro­cess of start­ing a busi­ness, I ini­tially thought this would be a great way to advert­ise my com­pany. Unfor­tu­nat­ley — my google searches about a month ago brought up noth­ing. One of my part­ners actu­ally re-scheduled an import­ant busi­ness meet­ing to be avail­able. These people are vul­tures — they prey on those that actu­ally pro­duce.  Its really sad to see what people go through to swindle oth­ers out of money.
    If someone is actu­ally read­ing this from ‘Heart­beat of Amer­ica’ — under­stand that you are pro­du­cing NO VALUE. Your con­tri­bu­tion to soci­ety is NOTHING. Because of your work NO per­sons qual­ity of life is improved — except per­haps your own. But even that is ques­tion­able — when was the last time you didn’t have to avert your eyes when look­ing your­self in the mir­ror.
    Change your life — become some­thing bet­ter — work as some­thing that actu­ally brings value to those around you. Good Luck.

  49. John Kiplinger | Apr 22, 2006 at 11:05 am | Permalink

    I had a meet­ing with them at my office and by mis­take they left behind their con­fid­en­tial bro­chure which is given to only those who appear on the program.

    Check it out! Below is a word for word quote from this bro­chure. It details the way the pro­gram works.

    Some of you might be inter­ested. If what they’re say­ing is for real it looks pretty good.

    Step one: An ini­tial wel­come aboard tele­phone call and pack­age for those who are invited to participate.

    Step two: Ana­lyze com­pany inform­a­tion and develop ques­tions and answers for the tele­vi­sion news inter­view to be con­duc­ted at our tele­vi­sion stu­dios by a top level news anchor and reporter. Dur­ing this pro­cess we would also be cre­at­ing the import­ant intro­duc­tion to your com­pany. The anchor/reporter intro­duc­tions, the inter­view, the award present­a­tion, Mr. Shatner’s and the Admiral’s intro­duc­tions set the stage for the inter­view. They are all struc­tured by Heart­beat to cre­ate the cred­ib­il­ity of the news broadcast.

    Step three: The cre­ation of the per­son­al­ized KEEPING AMERICA STRONG award that is intro­duced by the Admiral and presen­ted by the news anchor on the show.

    Step four: Dis­cuss­ing the edit of the thirty minute tele­vi­sion show–including the main com­pany inter­view and all the other celebrity per­form­ances into three parts that would ulti­mately end up on busi­ness card CD-Rom and three dif­fer­ent videos and con­tent for web­site use.

    Step five: Assist­ing the com­pany with trans­port­a­tion and hotel arrange­ments for the tele­vi­sion shoot at the Santa Bar­bara stu­dio. Com­plete make-up ser­vices will be avail­able at the studio.

    Step six: An in depth script con­fer­ence and rehearsal with the dir­ector and the news anchor/reporter on the day of inter­view at the studio.

    Step seven: Fol­low­ing the tele­vi­sion inter­view, Heart­beat sends a cam­era­man to the company’s loc­a­tion or any other site or loc­a­tion to film B-Roll of the organ­iz­a­tion in action. This is then edited into the inter­view dur­ing post production.

    Step eight: Com­bin­ing all the ele­ments to cre­ate the com­plete thirty minute TV show. Fol­low­ing that, Heart­beat will edit con­densed ver­sions of the show for a wallet-sized busi­ness card CD-Rom, and three dif­fer­ent videos.

    Step nine: The final stage is the air­ing of the thirty minute show on national cable tele­vi­sion. We also deliver your per­son­al­ized mas­ter copy of the thirty minute show. Most import­antly you will receive a mas­ter of a wallet-sized busi­ness card CD as well as mas­ters of the edited down videos to make cop­ies for trade shows, dir­ect mail, sales reps, web­sites etc. Included in the pack­age will be sample VHS and CD copies.

    Step ten: Using the pro­gram to increase rev­en­ues. There are many ways to use the busi­ness CD-Rom, Videos, and Web­site to open doors and cre­ate new rev­en­ues. The pur­pose of Keep­ing Amer­ica Strong is to help small, entre­pren­eur­ial com­pan­ies. Heart­beat of Amer­ica will always be there to coun­sel com­pan­ies to max­im­ize the use of the program.

  50. Miranda | Apr 30, 2006 at 11:06 pm | Permalink

    What is every­one so upset about? It’s a busi­ness just like any other busi­ness. You get what you pay for and if it doesn’t look like some­thing you want, then don’t buy it. It’s not like they’re tak­ing your money and giv­ing you no product…which is what I think of when I think of a scam. It is what it is…and if it can bene­fit your com­pany then it’s the best thing in the world…if it can’t or you don’t have the money then carry on…no big deal. It’s not going to be right for every­one. But for many com­pan­ies it has accom­plished a mir­acle at a price that is pretty darn affordable…especially given the names you get to use. I mean you can say what you want to I guess…but one thing you also don’t see any­where on here is someone who actu­ally did the pro­gram and was unsat­is­fied with the result…only people who didn’t for one reason or another. It’s not like Wil­liam Shat­ner is really going to call you him­self. No pro­gram works that way. Every­one is entitled to an opinion…but please keep things in per­spect­ive and be fair.

  51. Sharon Lewis | May 22, 2006 at 12:03 pm | Permalink

    I also met with them and they played a video in my office, well I had a hid­den tape recorder going through the entire inter­view! I thought you all may be inter­ested! See, I taped a copy of their recor­ded present­a­tion because I’m and old fan of Doug Llewellyn and I thought you might be inter­ested on how he intro­duced a guest which is on their tape and this is what he says.:

    AROUND THE WORLD THERE ARE CHILDREN AND ADULTS WHO CANNOT GET THE HEALTHCARE THEY NEED. THE TECHNOLOGY AND THE EXPERIENCED MEDICAL SURGEONS, DOCTORS AND NURSES ARE NOT AVAILABLE OR IT IS TOO COSTLY. SO THE QUESTION IS WHAT CAN BE DONE?

    IN 1997 AN ORGANIZATION CALLED THE WORLD SURGICAL FOUNDATION STEPPED UP TO THE PLATE TO DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT AND EVER SINCE THEY HAVE BEEN TAKING CRITICAL HEALTHCARE WHERE IT HAS NOT PREVIOUSLY BEEN AVAILABLE.

    BEFORE WE FIND OUT MORE FROM THE FOUNDER OF THE ORGANIZATION THAT WE ARE TALKING ABOUT LET ME TAKE A MOMENT TO READ A FEW STATEMENTS FROM SOME NOTABLE OFFICIALS FROM OUR GOVERNMENT.

    Doug Llewellyn then goes on to read some pos­it­ive state­ments from Gov­ernors. I must say I was impressed.

  52. Rebecca | Jun 13, 2006 at 7:08 pm | Permalink

    After read­ing each com­ment, this is what I think. It seems like “Heart­beat of Amer­ica” is not a scam and not a char­ity, but a busi­ness which is selling a mar­ket­ing tool (“cred­ib­il­ity” in the form of a video with Shat­ner, news anchors, etc.) at the going rate/reasonable price.

    Neg­at­ives:
    1) They seem to be offer­ing their ser­vices to every pos­sible busi­ness they can find and telling us that we’re spe­cial.
    2) There are some ques­tion­able sales tac­tics being used such as say­ing that the offer is for a lim­ited time (going on 3 years, now?), per­haps over prom­ising on how valu­able a mar­ket­ing tool this could be and some people repor­ted a high-pressure present­a­tion (which I myself did not exper­i­ence at all when I met with them).
    3) There are some neg­at­ive com­ments from people who claim to have worked for the com­pany. (If it’s really that bad, why is Shat­ner asso­ci­ated with it and why aren’t we hear­ing from dis­gruntled customers/businesses?)

    As I look at what I can say are neg­at­ives, the list doesn’t actu­ally seem that ser­i­ous. I find it inter­est­ing that not one neg­at­ive com­ment has been left by a busi­ness owner who pur­chased their pro­duc­tion ser­vices and was dis­ap­poin­ted. Also, “Heart­beat of Amer­ica” is lis­ted with the BBB without any neg­at­ive what­so­ever. It all comes down to: what are you get­ting for $15,000 and will you see a return on your investment?

    To have a video present­a­tion of my products asso­ci­ated with Shat­ner and Llewelyn may be worth that to me. How­ever, fin­an­cially this is not the right time for me to put up $15,000 and since their price has remained stable for the past few years (!), I don’t think I need to be in any hurry. So, I’m plan­ning on giv­ing it 6 months and then re-evaluating.

    Every­one, thanks for your com­ments. They have helped me cla­rify my pos­i­tion on all this.

  53. Ramsay Seikaly | Feb 16, 2007 at 3:08 pm | Permalink

    My name is Ram­say Seikaly I have been with the organ­iz­a­tion referred to in this blog for some five years. I believe in inter­net blogs because they rep­res­ent Amer­ican demo­cracy giv­ing people the oppor­tun­ity to express openly their ideas and beliefs. How­ever, unfor­tu­nately there are a few out there who use it to vent their per­sonal grudges to falsely poison the minds of oth­ers therein harm­ing the good work of many good organ­iz­a­tions through­out our coun­try. Case in point: About a year ago, a dis­gruntled employee placed most of the com­plaints on this blog using false iden­tit­ies or no iden­tit­ies without any­one able to con­tact her and to respond to her fab­ric­ated state­ments. A fam­ous politi­cian once said, “You can run but you can’t hide”. Unfor­tu­nately, these people run and they do hide. Once again, his­tory repeats itself. A recent post­ing on the blog signed by an ex-employee without identi­fy­ing his or her­self made false state­ments degrad­ing the good people involved in this organ­iz­a­tion. An example is the auda­city to state that we hire stu­dents to pro­duce the show in order to save money when the real­ity is that the show is pro­duced in a major, highly acclaimed Hol­ly­wood Stu­dio where net­work news shows shoot seg­ments with top-level cam­era, light­ing and pro­duc­tion pro­fes­sion­als who have done the major shows for many, many years. They would be out­raged by someone call­ing them “Stu­dents”. Another point: this poor soul thinks they can pro­duce a thirty minute tele­vi­sion show includ­ing three dif­fer­ent 10 minute mar­ket­ing videos with a fam­ous net­work TV host with 15 years on a national pro­gram sup­por­ted by Net­work News Anchors, an Admiral, in addi­tion to all of that an A List Celebrity Icon known by every­one in Amer­ica that adds the ulti­mate cred­ib­il­ity to the pro­gram for, and get this, $7,000. If this per­son can do this for us, we hereby go on record to make this offi­cial offer: WE WILL PAY THIS PERSON A HUGE SUM OF MONEY TO PRODUCE THE ABOVE FOR OUR COMPANY FOR THE AMOUNT THEY CLAIM TO BE OUR COST. LET THIS PERSON SURFACE AND RECEIVE THE INCOME OF A LIFETIME.
    Without dig­ni­fy­ing, all of the rest of the absurd and twis­ted state­ments by respond­ing to them and wast­ing a lot of need­less time I will con­clude with the fol­low­ing REAL FACTS.

    1. WE HAVE DONE APPROXIMATELY 800 SHOWS AND BELIEVE IT OR NOT THERE IS NOT ANY KNOWN COMPLAINT FROM ANY OF THE 800 CLIENTS FROM NATIONAL AND LOCAL BETTER BUSINESS BUREAUS. THIS IS PROBABLY A FIRST IN THE HISTORY OF BUSINESS.

    2. WE HAVE RECEIVED MANY LETTERS FROM DOZENS AND DOZENS OF CLIENTS AND SOME 800 TELEPHONE CALLS FROM THEM THANKING US FOR THE GOOD WE ARE DOING FOR THEIR BUSINESS AND THE ECONOMY OF OUR COUNTRY AND ALSO FOR ASSOCIATING THEIR IMAGE WITH GIANT NAMES WORTH IN THE HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS AND MORE.

    These are the real facts and not the dis­tor­ted, twis­ted ver­biage of an unhappy soul look­ing to dam­age the repu­ta­tion of a good organ­iz­a­tion, good staff and good busi­nesses that have appeared on the show. We are an open book. My name again is Ram­say Seikaly. My per­sonal e-mail is ramdonseik@hotmail.com. I am for real. If this last so-called ex-employee is for real, let this per­son identify him­self or her­self and e-mail so that these false and vicious state­ments can be dis­cussed in the open.

  54. Ramsay Seikaly | Feb 16, 2007 at 3:10 pm | Permalink

    My name is Ram­say Seikaly I have been with the organ­iz­a­tion referred to in this blog for some five years. I believe in inter­net blogs because they rep­res­ent Amer­ican demo­cracy giv­ing people the oppor­tun­ity to express openly their ideas and beliefs. How­ever, unfor­tu­nately there are a few out there who use it to vent their per­sonal grudges to falsely poison the minds of oth­ers therein harm­ing the good work of many good organ­iz­a­tions through­out our coun­try. Case in point: About a year ago, a dis­gruntled employee placed most of the com­plaints on this blog using false iden­tit­ies or no iden­tit­ies without any­one able to con­tact her and to respond to her fab­ric­ated state­ments. A fam­ous politi­cian once said, “You can run but you can’t hide”. Unfor­tu­nately, these people run and they do hide. Once again, his­tory repeats itself. A recent post­ing on the blog signed by an ex-employee without identi­fy­ing his or her­self made false state­ments degrad­ing the good people involved in this organ­iz­a­tion. An example is the auda­city to state that we hire stu­dents to pro­duce the show in order to save money when the real­ity is that the show is pro­duced in a major, highly acclaimed Hol­ly­wood Stu­dio where net­work news shows shoot seg­ments with top-level cam­era, light­ing and pro­duc­tion pro­fes­sion­als who have done the major shows for many, many years. They would be out­raged by someone call­ing them “Stu­dents”. Another point: this poor soul thinks they can pro­duce a thirty minute tele­vi­sion show includ­ing three dif­fer­ent 10 minute mar­ket­ing videos with a fam­ous net­work TV host with 15 years on a national pro­gram sup­por­ted by Net­work News Anchors, an Admiral, in addi­tion to all of that an A List Celebrity Icon known by every­one in Amer­ica that adds the ulti­mate cred­ib­il­ity to the pro­gram for, and get this, $7,000. If this per­son can do this for us, we hereby go on record to make this offi­cial offer: WE WILL PAY THIS PERSON A HUGE SUM OF MONEY TO PRODUCE THE ABOVE FOR OUR COMPANY FOR THE AMOUNT THEY CLAIM TO BE OUR COST. LET THIS PERSON SURFACE AND RECEIVE THE INCOME OF A LIFETIME.
    Without dig­ni­fy­ing, all of the rest of the absurd and twis­ted state­ments by respond­ing to them and wast­ing a lot of need­less time I will con­clude with the fol­low­ing REAL FACTS.

    1. WE HAVE DONE APPROXIMATELY 800 SHOWS AND BELIEVE IT OR NOT THERE IS NOT ANY KNOWN COMPLAINT FROM ANY OF THE 800 CLIENTS FROM NATIONAL AND LOCAL BETTER BUSINESS BUREAUS. THIS IS PROBABLY A FIRST IN THE HISTORY OF BUSINESS.

    2. WE HAVE RECEIVED MANY LETTERS FROM DOZENS AND DOZENS OF CLIENTS AND SOME 800 TELEPHONE CALLS FROM THEM THANKING US FOR THE GOOD WE ARE DOING FOR THEIR BUSINESS AND THE ECONOMY OF OUR COUNTRY AND ALSO FOR ASSOCIATING THEIR IMAGE WITH GIANT NAMES WORTH IN THE HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS AND MORE.

    These are the real facts and not the dis­tor­ted, twis­ted ver­biage of an unhappy soul look­ing to dam­age the repu­ta­tion of a good organ­iz­a­tion, good staff and good busi­nesses that have appeared on the show. We are an open book. My name again is Ram­say Seikaly. My per­sonal e-mail is ramdonseik@hotmail.com. I am for real. If this last so-called ex-employee is for real, let this per­son identify him­self or her­self and e-mail so that these false and vicious state­ments can be dis­cussed in the open.

  55. Lauren Wood | Feb 16, 2007 at 4:32 pm | Permalink

    I think there have now been enough com­ments on this pro­gram on this blog; since I find it unlikely that any­body is going to say any­thing new I am clos­ing com­ments for this entry.

{ 2 } Trackbacks

  1. Dare Obasanjo aka Carnage4Life | Mar 10, 2005 at 8:19 pm | Permalink

    Bring­ing Affirm­at­ive Action to Blogging

  2. Quote of the Day | Mar 11, 2005 at 4:43 am | Permalink

    via Lauren Wood | The Power of Paper

    While the post isnt about this sub­ject I found the fol­low­ing sound bite really neat: …still have the fax with the details of what I missed out on. Maybe I’ll keep that for pos­ter­ity; after all, paper doesn’t degrade the…