Oct 042005

Now that the XML Catalog specification has been approved as an OASIS Standard, it feels like the end of an era to me. I’ve been chairing the Entity Resolution Technical Committee since its inception way back in October 2000 , working with a good group of people. As Norm put it today, we’d be happy to work on any standard with this group. Everyone working together, no posturing, no weird agendas, just people trying to find the best solution to a problem. It made the group easy to chair, and I’m confident the results reflect that; I can’t help but suspect that dysfunctional committee politics results in specifications that are not as good as they could have been.

So I’m a little nostalgic right now, remembering the first discussions, the meetings at conferences, as well as the break we took in the middle before deciding to go for that “OASIS Standard” moniker. The TC still has 3 of the original 4 co-proposers (Norm Walsh, Paul Grosso, and me; John Cowan had to pull out part-way through due to work obligations). New people joined, and others left, but overall we had a pretty stable group.

So I want to thank the members of the ER TC, both past and present, and also Mary McRae and Robin Cover of OASIS. Your good humour, desire to do the right thing, and willingness to put in the effort all meant a lot and made it possible to finalize the specification and show members of OASIS why it’s useful. I’d also like to thank the implementors of the catalog spec who proved that it’s implementable! I believe catalogs will be widely used in the future, even if, like much XML plumbing, people won’t actually see a catalog very often.

So feel free to drop by the Sun booth at XML 2005 to talk about catalogs; either Norm or I are likely to be there and Norm will have his catalog implementation on his laptop to show people (along with a bunch of other things, of course).

  7 Responses to “End of an Era”

  1. Lauren, your link is mis-formatted at the beginning of the post. The sentence should read “Now that the XML Catalog specification has been approved as an OASIS Standard…” and it should link to:


    Looks like you missed a > bracket.

  2. Thanks for catching that, it’s now fixed.

  3. Actually I left because my employer quit OASIS.

  4. John, I figured your employer leaving OASIS fell into the category of “work obligations”. I’m happy for you to tell the details, of course.

  5. OASIS approves XML Catalog 1.1

    OASIS has approved the XML Catalog 1.1 spec. So, it is up to you all now to go out and use it. I hope a lot of you will find it useful (many already find the 1.0 spec useful, and

  6. There really aren’t any to speak of. After a disastrous 2002, Reuters’s first money-losing year since going public (possibly its first in a century-and-a-half history), Reuters bailed out of almost all the consortia and such that it belonged to, including Unicode, OASIS, and W3C, in order to save money.

    Anyhow, my work obligations didn’t change. However, Reuters is letting me go shortly (possibly as soon as December 31), so any leads to new employment will be helpful.’

    BTW, I really really hate this instant preview mode; on a moderately slow machine like this one, it makes typing really intolerable. I feel like I’m back on an overloaded timesharing system with up to sevefral seconds’ declay dbefore I can see what I’m typing. (I left the typos alone in that sentence to give you an idea.)

  7. Did anybody try XML 1.0 (Second Edition)???I’ve got some trable with an entity catalog …

Leave a Reply to Lauren Wood Cancel reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>



/* ]]> */